Forums

F.A.Q. F.A.Q.    Register Register    Login Login    Home Home
Search Search
SBML Discussions » sbml-discuss » SBML survey: should consistency of units be required?
Show: Today's Posts  :: Message Navigator
| Subscribe to topic 
Return to the default flat view Create a new topic Submit Reply
AuthorTopic
Sven Sahle


Posts: 82
Registered:
September 2003
Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be required? 16 Dec '07 14:23 Go to previous messageGo to previous message

Hello Robert,

Am 16.12.2007 um 22:06 schrieb <rphair@integrativebioinformatics.com>:

> Hugh-
>
> I’m not convinced otherwise yet, but probably I will be when you
> tell me why one of these wouldn’t work:
>
>
> d(glucose)/dt = k1*potatoStarch + k2*barleyStarch
>
> or
>
> d(glucose)/dt = k1*amylase*potatoStarch/(Kmps + potatoStarch) +
> k2*amylase*barleyStarch/(Kmbs + barleyStarch)
>
Both these equations work with the current strict specification. If
you do not specify explicitly the units for k1 and k2 they are assumed
to be so that the overall equation has consistent units, which could
be figured out by a tool.
If, however, you do explicitly specify the units of k1 and k2 (the
specification does not force you to do so), they really should be the
right units to make it consistent.

The only thing you cannot do in sbml right now is to write an
assignment rule like "concentration of species A = volume of
compartment C". If you really want to do this you would have to write
" concentration of species A = volume of compartment C * 1", where the
units of "1" are assumed to be so that the whole thing is consistent.

Sven


Dr. Sven Sahle
Abteilung Modellierung biologischer Prozesse
Universität Heidelberg, BIOQUANT/Zoologie



____________________________________________________________
To manage your sbml-discuss list subscription, visit
https://utils.its.caltech.edu/mailman/listinfo/sbml-discuss

For a web interface to the sbml-discuss mailing list, visit
http://sbml.org/forums/

For questions or feedback about the sbml-discuss list,
contact sbml-team@caltech.edu.


      

SubjectPosterDate
Read Message   SBML survey: should consistency of units be requir... Mike Hucka14 Dec '07 19:06
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Sven Sahle15 Dec '07 12:48
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Nicolas Le Novere15 Dec '07 16:03
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Nicolas Le Novere15 Dec '07 16:03
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Sarah Keating16 Dec '07 09:59
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... hugh.d.spence15 Dec '07 13:12
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Nicolas Le Novere15 Dec '07 16:07
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... hugh.d.spence15 Dec '07 23:42
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Schaff16 Dec '07 06:13
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Robert Phair16 Dec '07 13:06
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re...  Sven Sahle16 Dec '07 14:23
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... hugh.d.spence17 Dec '07 03:42
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Robert Phair15 Dec '07 15:06
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Nicolas Le Novere15 Dec '07 16:14
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of unitsbe req... Robert Phair15 Dec '07 16:59
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Schaff15 Dec '07 22:02
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Sven Sahle16 Dec '07 06:03
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Jordan Atlas16 Dec '07 10:23
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Jordan Atlas16 Dec '07 11:46
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Sven Sahle16 Dec '07 14:06
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Frank Bergmann16 Dec '07 14:36
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Stefan.Hoops17 Dec '07 14:11
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Nicolas Le Novere17 Dec '07 14:39
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Stefan.Hoops17 Dec '07 15:06
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Pedro Mendes18 Dec '07 01:05
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Nicolas Le Novere16 Dec '07 15:17
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency ofunitsbe requ... Schaff15 Dec '07 22:09
Read Message   Re: SBML survey: should consistency of units be re... Sven Sahle16 Dec '07 14:39
Read Message   Results of survey: should consistency of units be ... Mike Hucka01 Jan '08 19:18
Previous Topic:Results of Hackathon date preference survey
Next Topic:2008 Hackathon date survey
Go to forum:
-=] Back to Top [=-

Powered by FUDforum. (Copyright Advanced Internet Designs Inc.)

Please use our issue tracking system for any questions or suggestions about this website.