Forums

F.A.Q. F.A.Q.    Register Register    Login Login    Home Home
Search Search
SBML Discussions » sbml-discuss » stoichiometries of modifiers
Show: Today's Posts  :: Message Navigator
| Subscribe to topic 
Return to the default flat view Create a new topic Submit Reply
AuthorTopic
Darren J Wilkinson


Posts: 73
Registered:
September 2003
Re: stoichiometries of modifiers 30 Apr '05 00:47 Go to previous messageGo to previous message

Emek Demir wrote:
> If this is only a visualization problem, you can always keep the long
> complex formation notation in SBML and then at the visualization layer
> you can do something about it. If things are that simple, then it should
> be a no brainer. PATIKA for example goes to a great length to be able to
> manage complexity at the visualization layer. No one will scream at
> anyone for putting a nice 2 on a modifier edge in visualization layer.
> However when you want to introduce ambigous abstractions for the sake of
> visual brevity and at the cost of your fellow SBML parser programmer,
> chances are they won't like it at all..
> ;)

At one level I agree - as I've said in previous posts, this isn't an
issue I feel particularly strongly about. What I really objected to was
the suggestion that this was a half-baked idea from a person who was so
ignorant/stupid that they couldn't pass a basic enzyme-kinetics course!
It clearly isn't. So we agree that it isn't strictly necessary, but as I
said, SBML has lots of features that aren't stricltly necessary... The
question is, will it really make those that don't need it that unhappy?
I don't see why it should.

--
Darren Wilkinson
email: mailto:darrenjwilkinson@btinternet.com
work web: http://www.staff.ncl.ac.uk/d.j.wilkinson/
home web: http://www.darrenjwilkinson.btinternet.co.uk/



      

SubjectPosterDate
Read Message   stoichiometries of modifiers Hiroyuki Kuwahara25 Apr '05 09:56
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Pedro Mendes25 Apr '05 13:39
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers emek25 Apr '05 14:26
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Hiroyuki Kuwahara25 Apr '05 18:08
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers emek26 Apr '05 01:14
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Hiroyuki Kuwahara26 Apr '05 08:52
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers emek26 Apr '05 11:24
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Herbert Sauro25 Apr '05 14:40
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers zucker25 Apr '05 16:27
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Hiroyuki Kuwahara25 Apr '05 18:09
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard25 Apr '05 19:14
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Pedro Mendes26 Apr '05 05:30
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard26 Apr '05 10:27
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Stefan Hoops26 Apr '05 15:16
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Greg Blumenthal26 Apr '05 16:01
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Nicolas Le Novere27 Apr '05 01:29
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka27 Apr '05 21:07
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard26 Apr '05 16:38
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Pedro Mendes26 Apr '05 17:22
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard26 Apr '05 17:36
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Pedro Mendes26 Apr '05 19:01
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard26 Apr '05 20:25
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers J.Weimar27 Apr '05 01:06
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard27 Apr '05 08:43
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Pedro Mendes27 Apr '05 10:32
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Stefan Hoops27 Apr '05 11:02
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Darren J Wilkinson27 Apr '05 12:55
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard27 Apr '05 14:55
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Ben Bornstein27 Apr '05 15:56
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Tomas Radivoyevitch27 Apr '05 18:47
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka27 Apr '05 20:46
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard27 Apr '05 23:25
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard28 Apr '05 09:12
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Andrew Finney07 May '05 01:59
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Andrew Finney07 May '05 01:59
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka17 Jun '05 18:52
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka27 Apr '05 20:52
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard27 Apr '05 23:41
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Stefan Hoops28 Apr '05 04:56
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Stefan Hoops28 Apr '05 08:31
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Howard28 Apr '05 10:34
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Upinder Singh Bhalla28 Apr '05 19:34
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka07 May '05 05:29
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Upinder Singh Bhalla07 May '05 05:48
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka13 May '05 18:08
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Andrew Finney22 May '05 00:21
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka17 Jun '05 18:47
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Pedro Mendes28 Apr '05 05:34
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Andrew Finney07 May '05 01:59
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Ed Frank27 Apr '05 08:17
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka28 Apr '05 00:40
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Ed Frank28 Apr '05 07:45
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Darren J Wilkinson29 Apr '05 14:31
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers emek29 Apr '05 15:15
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers  Darren J Wilkinson30 Apr '05 00:47
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka07 May '05 05:29
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Pedro Mendes07 May '05 22:14
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Stefan Hoops27 Apr '05 04:00
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers ginkel27 Apr '05 12:12
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Hiroyuki Kuwahara26 Apr '05 11:17
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers Mike Hucka27 Apr '05 21:49
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too &qu... Darren J Wilkinson26 Apr '05 14:12
Read Message   is SBML too"narrow"? Nicolas Le Novere26 Apr '05 14:56
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Mike Hucka26 Apr '05 19:26
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Sven Sahle27 Apr '05 01:23
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Mike Hucka27 Apr '05 21:36
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Nicolas Le Novere28 Apr '05 00:50
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Ed Frank28 Apr '05 07:57
Read Message   RE: is SBML too"narrow"? Andrew Finney07 May '05 01:59
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Nicolas Le Novere27 Apr '05 01:35
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Rainer Machne28 Apr '05 06:13
Read Message   Re: is SBML too"narrow"? Fabien Campagne28 Apr '05 11:33
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too &q... Pedro Mendes26 Apr '05 15:15
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too &qu... Mike Hucka26 Apr '05 20:55
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too&quo... Tomas Radivoyevitch26 Apr '05 22:23
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too&quo... Mike Hucka27 Apr '05 21:59
Read Message   SBML packaging Nicolas Le Novere28 Apr '05 00:59
Read Message   Re: SBML packaging Mike Hucka02 May '05 00:29
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too &qu... Darren J Wilkinson27 Apr '05 12:47
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too &qu... Mike Hucka06 May '05 03:16
Read Message   Re: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too &q... Pedro Mendes07 May '05 21:32
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers - is SBML too&quo... Andrew Finney07 May '05 01:59
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Andrew Finney07 May '05 01:59
Read Message   RE: stoichiometries of modifiers Herbert Sauro13 May '05 18:17
Previous Topic:New Version of SBW
Next Topic:Complementary Alternative to MathML Needed
Go to forum:
-=] Back to Top [=-

Powered by FUDforum. (Copyright Advanced Internet Designs Inc.)

Please use our issue tracking system for any questions or suggestions about this website.