Forums

F.A.Q. F.A.Q.    Register Register    Login Login    Home Home
Search Search
SBML Discussions » sbml-discuss » Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rate laws
Show: Today's Posts  :: Message Navigator
| Subscribe to topic 
Return to the default flat view Create a new topic Submit Reply
AuthorTopic
Herbert Sauro


Posts: 349
Registered:
September 2003
RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rate laws 21 Jul '05 14:52 Go to previous message



-----Original Message-----
From: Nicolas Le Novère [mailto:lenov@ebi.ac.uk]
Sent: Thursday, July 21, 2005 1:43 PM
To: SBML Discussion List
Subject: RE: [sbml-discuss] Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rate laws

> The problem I have with local parameters is that in scripting
> languages such as matlab or jarnac (even jdesigner for that
> matter) one has to prefix the names with the reaction name since these
> languages don't have the concept of local rate constants.

>Fine. This is a tool problem, not an SBML one.

You're right, but it is a real pain. Hence the move to global parameters, it eliminates the problem altogether. Don't know why I didn't do it before.

>Hold-on. There is no rule in SBML that says you have to conserve IDs.
>Therefore, you can rewrite all the parameter ids from scratch each time.
>That solve the problem of incremental increase of the size.

Some of us get models from different sources other than SBML, yes there are other ways to represent models, and I don't see why SBML has be be dealt with as a special case.

Herbert


--
Nicolas LE NOVÈRE, Computational Neurobiology, EMBL-EBI, Wellcome-Trust Genome Campus, Hinxton, Cambridge, CB10 1SD, UK
Tel: +44(0)1223 494 521, Fax: +44(0)1223 494 468, Mob: +33(0)689218676 http://www.ebi.ac.uk/~lenov




      

SubjectPosterDate
Read Message   Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rate la... Mike Hucka17 Jun '05 18:28
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... bshapiro17 Jun '05 19:15
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka29 Jun '05 08:04
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Andrew Finney18 Jun '05 07:19
Read Message   Annoucement: TERANODE Design Suite 2.7 Available &... Zheng Li20 Jun '05 13:33
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka05 Jul '05 00:02
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere05 Jul '05 01:35
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka05 Jul '05 10:21
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere05 Jul '05 11:33
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka16 Jul '05 01:10
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Howard16 Jul '05 09:50
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Matt Halstead16 Jul '05 16:59
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka18 Jul '05 00:28
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Matt Halstead18 Jul '05 01:56
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka19 Jul '05 00:33
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Matt Halstead19 Jul '05 18:52
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka20 Jul '05 17:40
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Howard20 Jul '05 18:42
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka20 Jul '05 20:09
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Darren J Wilkinson21 Jul '05 01:19
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere21 Jul '05 07:51
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Howard21 Jul '05 08:09
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere21 Jul '05 14:13
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka21 Jul '05 19:14
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Sven Sahle22 Jul '05 06:39
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Howard22 Jul '05 08:44
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Howard05 Jul '05 10:23
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere05 Jul '05 11:38
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka18 Jul '05 12:02
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere18 Jun '05 12:48
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Herbert Sauro20 Jun '05 23:56
Read Message   Re: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Howard22 Jun '05 19:14
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Herbert Sauro21 Jul '05 13:08
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere21 Jul '05 14:16
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... rphair21 Jul '05 19:42
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing ra... Nicolas Le Novere22 Jul '05 01:10
Read Message   Global vs. local parameters (was: Proposal: simple... Pedro Mendes22 Jul '05 07:01
Read Message   Re: Global vs. local parameters Nicholas Allen22 Jul '05 08:38
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Mike Hucka22 Jul '05 15:33
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Herbert Sauro21 Jul '05 14:32
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat... Nicolas Le Novere21 Jul '05 14:43
Read Message   RE: Proposal: simple mechanism for referencing rat...  Herbert Sauro21 Jul '05 14:52
Previous Topic:RE: Global vs. local parameters (was: Proposal: simple mechanism forreferencing ratelaws)
Next Topic:RE: Global vs. local parameters (was: Proposal: simple mechanism forreferencing ratelaws)
Go to forum:
-=] Back to Top [=-

Powered by FUDforum. (Copyright Advanced Internet Designs Inc.)

Please use our issue tracking system for any questions or suggestions about this website.